Finally the Final Kitchen

If I actually wrote a blog post for every time I said to Kyle, “I’ll write a blog post about this!” … we’d have a more interesting blog.

Anyway. Here is the finally finished post on our finally finished kitchen renovation! Here is what we did and how we got to the finish line of a kitchen that’s what we wanted (mostly, at least).

While plotting and planning the cabinets and kitchen layout (which took two years, by the way), we received a lot of “well you have to think about the resale” comments. People told us to, “keep it neutral” so we could sell the house without offending any potential buyers. Well, I wasn’t going to renovate the kitchen to sell; I’m renovating to live! By the time we sell the house, anything “standard” today would be out of date anyway … so dammit, we’re doing what we want.

To put it simply, we’re a bit obsessive about details, and like time to think through problems. Using the Ikea Home Design tool we were able to sketch out different layouts and play around with where we wanted to put our appliances. Ikea’s tool is accessible through their website, and free, and somewhat easy to use once you get the hang of it – which I found to be two seconds before I gave up completely.

My word of advice for anyone looking to go the Ikea self-design route: Do not start from scratch unless you’re an actual kitchen designer. Find a kitchen to replicate in terms of layout and build that. We tried from scratch and it took forever and didn’t turn out well…

When we started, we had no intention of actually using Ikea cabinets. Then, suddenly we were obsessed with Ikea cabinets for these reasons:
1. There are a bazilion great reviews
2. They would be cheap
3. They have something crazy like a 30 year warranty on them

Just one problem: we saw this photo and instantly wanted blue cabinets…

How beautiful is that kitchen? It’s everything. Just one problem: Ikea doesn’t carry blue. And, now only blue would do.

Finding blue cabinets was no easy feat. We started out with trying to find the exact cabinets in this photo, but as it turns out those beauties cost more than a Tesla. We don’t live in Potomac so had to try something different.

After searching near and far for a mid-tier cabinet brand we found a few companies that make custom doors for Ikea cabinets. I priced them all:
– Local shop I can’t remember the name of …

I could have gone either way, and we were going to go with SemiHandmade up until I started talking more to Scherr’s. Scherr’s, which is a custom shop in Minot, North Dakota,  had sent a note asking if I would like them to also quote a custom kitchen build. Meaning, rather than making only the doors for my Ikea cabinets, they could also build the cabinets themselves. All wood, dovetail drawers and all custom sized to fit my exact dimensions. Quotes cost nothing to get, so why not see what it would be?

As it turns out, it wasn’t much more expensive than the Ikea, and we would end up with significantly more cabinet space since they would custom fit into my oddly sized room. The cabinets came flat-packed (like Ikea) so our contractor quote already included a carpenter to assemble and install. And, even better: they’d paint them all the exact blue we were going for.

With their expert guidance on finalizing a cabinet design, our contractor’s final measurements and a hefty payment – we had an order placed for our cabinets! The only downside was that since the cabinets were custom ordered, and from a small operation, it took for-ev-er for them to be made. While some people have to wait 2-3 weeks for their cabinets, ours took about 11. Talk about torture.


IMG_4710 IMG_4748IMG_20170507_211325371

Once they did arrive though, it took only a week or so to get the boxes built and everything put together for the countertops. I’ll tell you what, this was MUCH more stressful than any other part of the project. Cabinets cost a small fortune, and watching a carpenter bang around them is enough to put anyone into a fit of crazy. Every evening I’d been inspecting the cabinets, looking for dings (there were plenty) and sending my contractor questions.

On one hand, since the cabinets are built to be “DIY” I wish we had done the DIY for this so that I could control the damage. On the other hand, there is no way Kyle and I could have assembled and installed the trim on the sides, top, and toe kicks as well as a professional carpenter, so it’s best we left the entire job to a professional. As angry as I might be about it all (and still am, months later), I’m glad we didn’t DIY.

That said, if we had a kitchen cabinet design that didn’t need to extend on both sides to the wall exactly, or to the ceiling as we wanted ours to, we should have DIY-ed the install.

Next in the string of design choices, was our beautiful countertops. These are quartz with a marble look to them, with the marbling blue & grey.


After the countertops went in we honestly believed it would just be another week and we’d be able to move out of the living room and start cooking actual meals. We were so wrong. It took weeks until we had plumbing hooked up (correctly), our appliances working, and the backsplash tile installed. This string of events, coupled with the disaster that was our floors is why it’s taken me so long to finish writing this blog post. Arguably the worst weeks of the project, waiting for it to be done and having our contractor disappear for days on end not supervising his workers.

We had to have the backsplash tiling redone twice. I won’t say more about it.

DSC_5700 DSC_5723


The cabinets are custom painted Sherwin Williams Naval. They’re pretty dark but lighter during the day with the sun coming in, and darker at night.

Something I will say about dark cabinets, if anyone would consider getting them, is that it’s not for the faint of heart. Think of them like you would buying a black dresser – any dust or dirt shows. Any nick in the paint, will stand out. You have to be prepared for these things.

On that note, I need to go do my weekly wipe-down of the cabinets.

2 thoughts on “Finally the Final Kitchen

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s